After learning that Noel and his family’s cabin had something to do with „that night” and possibly Maya’s disappearance, the girls work to try and put the pieces together. Hanna and Emily head out to the Kahn family cabin looking for clues linking Maya to the site, while Spencer does some snooping of her own on Noel. Could Noel have had a hand in this after all, or are he and Jenna just bluffing to send Aria, Emily, Hanna and Spencer down the wrong path?

Meanwhile, Aria must deal with the aftermath of meeting Ezra’s mom and the information about Ezra’s past.